Top court sets sentencing framework for cases involving Indigenous offenders, victims

Advertisement

Advertise with us

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada says in cases where an Indigenous offender commits an offence against an intimate partner who is an Indigenous woman, a judge must apply sentencing principles related to both Indigenous offenders and victims of crime in a harmonious way.

Read this article for free:


By clicking the button above, an account will be created and you will begin to receive some of our recommended newsletters. You may opt out of any newsletter by visiting your Email and Communication Preferences page or by clicking "unsubscribe" at the bottom of any email.

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $1.44 a week*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Billed as $5.77 plus GST every four weeks. After 52 weeks, price increases to the regular rate of $19.95 plus GST every four weeks. Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

OTTAWA – The Supreme Court of Canada says in cases where an Indigenous offender commits an offence against an intimate partner who is an Indigenous woman, a judge must apply sentencing principles related to both Indigenous offenders and victims of crime in a harmonious way.

In a 5-4 judgment Friday, the top court provided guidance and set out a new framework for determining an appropriate sentence in such cases.

The court said Indigenous people are disproportionately and excessively imprisoned, while Indigenous women and girls suffer from unacceptably high levels of violence and abuse.

It said both of these issues have been shaped by the experiences of colonization, and addressing them together is central to the ongoing process of reconciliation.

Parliament has tried to address both concerns through the criminal sentencing process, the court noted.

The Supreme Court said the sentencing methodology in such cases is not a mathematical formula but a guide to help judges take into account the circumstances of Indigenous offenders and the vulnerability of Indigenous women and girls to abuse and violence.

“Proportionality requires due attention to the circumstances of the offender and of the victim in light of relevant sentencing objectives,” Justice Michelle O’Bonsawin wrote on behalf of the majority. “The appropriate balancing will inevitably vary depending on the specific circumstances of the offence.”

The ruling comes in the case of a Mi’kmaq man with severe mental health challenges who was sentenced to five years in prison after pleading guilty to aggravated assault against his partner, a Mi’kmaq woman.

The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal reduced the sentence to three years, and the Supreme Court ruled Friday the three-year sentence should stand.

The top court found the sentencing judge did not recognize that the offender’s mental illness contributed to the commission of the aggravated assault and did not consider the effect of that illness on the relevant sentencing objectives.

The sentencing judge would have settled on a shorter prison term had she properly considered the offender’s significant mental health factors, particularly when viewed in light of a sentencing circle’s recommendations in the case, the Supreme Court said.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 9, 2026.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Mining industry appreciates support for critical mineral extraction in federal budget

Martin Cash 4 minute read Preview

Mining industry appreciates support for critical mineral extraction in federal budget

Martin Cash 4 minute read Thursday, Mar. 30, 2023

This week’s federal budget included an emphatic acknowledgment from the Trudeau government of the importance of the mining industry in this country, in particular the extraction and processing of so-called “critical minerals.”

Read
Thursday, Mar. 30, 2023

Cockerill’s already successful year keeps getting better

Mike McIntyre 3 minute read Preview

Cockerill’s already successful year keeps getting better

Mike McIntyre 3 minute read Wednesday, Mar. 29, 2023

Life is pretty rich these days for Aaron Cockerill.

Read
Wednesday, Mar. 29, 2023

Man pleads guilty to manslaughter for chasing, stabbing man downtown

Erik Pindera 3 minute read Preview

Man pleads guilty to manslaughter for chasing, stabbing man downtown

Erik Pindera 3 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

An intellectually disabled man who drunkenly chased down a man he had been arguing with and fatally stabbed him in broad daylight admitted to manslaughter on Wednesday.

Matthew Gerald Tomack Pelletier, now 38, chased Ricky Dwayne Mancheese, 49, down Kennedy Street before stabbing him six times in front of his wife on the sidewalk between Sargent and Cumberland avenues, at about 11:50 a.m. on June 11, 2024.

Pelletier, who police arrested the next day, was charged with second-degree murder, but instead pleaded guilty to the lesser offence of manslaughter in front of Court of King’s Bench Justice Joan McKelvey on Wednesday.

“This type of incident on Winnipeg streets is all too common and must be strongly deterred,” said McKelvey.

Read
2:00 AM CDT

Law will curb e-scooter enthusiasts

Editorial 4 minute read Preview

Law will curb e-scooter enthusiasts

Editorial 4 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

For people concerned about safety on Manitoba’s sidewalks and roadways, the province’s announcement that new rules will be introduced next year regarding the use of e-scooters and other personal electric vehicles (PEVs) was no doubt met with an enthusiastic “It’s about time.”

As their popularity and their presence among pedestrians on sidewalks and/or motor vehicles on the road has increased steadily, so have reports of close calls or, even worse, collisions involving e-scooters or other PEVs — including electric skateboards, hoverboards and unicycles — being operated imprudently and at unsafe speeds.

Traffic laws urgently need to be updated to govern the use of these conveyances, which up until now have remained in a regulatory grey area that has allowed PEVs to operate largely without guidelines and outside conventional avenues of traffic-safety enforcement. Accordingly, updates regarding PEV use will be included in the Highway Traffic Act in 2027.

The new legislation will govern such areas as mandatory helmet use, age restrictions, where PEVs can lawfully operate and the maximum speed at which they can travel (25 km/h). The aim of the new law, according to the province’s website, is “to help keep Manitobans safe when sharing roads, paths, and other public spaces.”

Read
2:00 AM CDT

Hit the brakes on driving lessons from mate

Maureen Scurfield 4 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

DEAR MISS LONELYHEARTS: I’ve been trying to learn to drive in busy traffic. My boyfriend said he would teach me, but he gets too playfully amorous while I’m trying to drive his new car in busier areas like downtown. He thinks it’s a big joke, but when I yelled that he was distracting me, he said, “Good.”

So I pulled over, slammed on the brakes and got out, thinking he would get back into the driver’s seat and drive us home, but he didn’t budge. He was being a real jerk.

I got back in, drove us to my place in silence, left the keys in the ignition and went inside and locked my door. Now we’re not talking and neither one of us is apologizing. What do you think?

— Still Mad, St. James

The currency of trust

Stephen Borys 6 minute read Preview

The currency of trust

Stephen Borys 6 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

Over the course of three weeks last month, I saw three very different sides of Dr. Ernest Cholakis — philanthropist, distinguished alumnus and dental surgeon.

The last of these was the most personal. And painful.

A week after watching Ernest receive the University of Manitoba’s distinguished alumni award for lifetime achievement — an honour for which I was one of his nominators — I arrived at his clinic with a tooth that had cracked in half. The pain had become considerable and, although his schedule was full, he found a way to fit me in.

Ernest has been my dentist for more than a decade, although our relationship has extended well beyond dentistry into friendship and a shared involvement in the cultural and community life of Winnipeg. I thought I knew him reasonably well. But helping to prepare his nomination introduced me to aspects of his professional life I had never fully appreciated.

Read
2:00 AM CDT