Giller winner not chosen until morning of awards

McNally Robinson’s Chris Hall talks about what went into selecting the best Canadian book of the year

Advertisement

Advertise with us

On Nov. 16, a fisherman/carpenter from Murray Harbour, P.E.I. took to a Toronto stage to accept one of Canada’s most lucrative literary prizes — 43-year-old Nicholas Herring had just been named the winner of the $100,000 Giller Prize for his sophomore novel Your Breath in Charcoal.

Read this article for free:


By clicking the button above, an account will be created and you will begin to receive some of our recommended newsletters. You may opt out of any newsletter by visiting your Email and Communication Preferences page or by clicking "unsubscribe" at the bottom of any email.

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Digital Subscription

One year of digital access for only $1.44 a week*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Billed as $5.77 plus GST every four weeks. After 52 weeks, price increases to the regular rate of $19.95 plus GST every four weeks. Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles
Start now

*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

On Nov. 16, a fisherman/carpenter from Murray Harbour, P.E.I. took to a Toronto stage to accept one of Canada’s most lucrative literary prizes — 43-year-old Nicholas Herring had just been named the winner of the $100,000 Giller Prize for his sophomore novel Your Breath in Charcoal.

Chosen from over 150 works of Canadian fiction, Herring’s novel follows a couple of Maritime lads in the 1990s who venture off the island to Ontario to try and make a go of it in construction. His book was chosen as this year’s Giller winner by a nine-person jury of independent booksellers from across Canada, a first for the prize.

Among those booksellers was McNally Robinson Booksellers co-owner Chris Hall.

MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS
                                McNally Robinson co-owner and Giller prize juror Chris Hall poses with a display of this year’s finalists.

MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS

McNally Robinson co-owner and Giller prize juror Chris Hall poses with a display of this year’s finalists.

Buy on mcnallyrobinson.com

The typical Giller jury is made up of five people: a mix of Canadian and international authors, including a former winner of the prize. In August 2025, however, Hall received a call from Giller Prize executive director Elana Rabinovitch asking if he would be interested in being a 2026 juror on a larger jury with other booksellers.

“I think I was the first one they called — I was quite happy and excited, and so I think that gave them confidence,” Hall said by phone the day after the Giller ceremony.

“They’d had a tough couple of years, so I think they were trying to feel their way back to something positive, accepted.”

Those tough years included boycotts by authors based on the Giller Prize’s former title sponsor, Scotiabank, and the financial institution’s ties to Elbit Systems, an Israeli arms supplier. Scotiabank divested itself of those ties but also exited as title sponsor of the Giller last year, after 20 years.

For their jury duties, each of the nine jurors received an e-reader loaded with some of the 150 books submitted for the prize, divvied up between them. After whittling away some of the books that most obviously wouldn’t be Giller-calibre works, a smaller group of titles was then discussed among jurors via video calls and eventually whittled down to a 10-book short list.

“Some of my theories of reading were confirmed — every reader is different. I’m fond of saying that we all take our own journey through the bookstore. We read books in different order, and different books, and it’s such a unique reading life, a unique experience,” Hall says.

He also noted that this year’s Governor General’s literary award, the Writers’ Trust fiction prize and the Giller short lists had no crossover books.

“That’s 15 unique books for the top three prizes — an indication of how subjective and individual reading is,” he says.

The conversations the Giller jurors had were spirited but never confrontational, Hall says.

“There was no arguing — there was debating, I guess, or sharing — that’s probably the best word, because it always felt like sharing our enthusiasm for a particular book or some disagreement. It happens at the bookstore, too.”

The jurors had an August deadline to narrow the submissions down to a 10-book long list and a five-book short list so organizers could deal with marketing, design and other such matters. The long list was announced Sept. 8, and the short list revealed on Oct. 5.

Hall and his fellow jurors selected Herring’s book as the winner on the morning of the ceremony, Nov. 16.

“We had a meeting in a private room in the hotel to decide who wins. I mean we couldn’t leak it, because we had no idea who it was,” he says.

The Canadian Press
                                Nicholas Herring’s Your Breath in Charcoal won the 2026 Giller Prize for English-language fiction.

The Canadian Press

Nicholas Herring’s Your Breath in Charcoal won the 2026 Giller Prize for English-language fiction.

The final discussion saw jurors systematically go through the five finalists over the course of an hour and a half, making cases for various titles and deciding which should win $100,000 prize. (The remaining finalists each received $10,000.)

Having an odd number of people on the jury meant there would be no tie — although in Hall’s mind, all the finalists are winners.

“My take is that a short list is just a tie for first. If the winner doesn’t appeal to you, read a different one. They’re all good books, and I’ve discovered some great authors by following that advice myself,” Hall says.

As a reader, juror and bookseller, Hall found the overall process rewarding and he had nothing but praise for Herring’s Giller-winning novel.

“(Your Breath in Charcoal) is a remarkable book at a sentence-by-sentence level. It’s this working-class young fellow who has the language you’d expect from a fisherman/construction worker,” he says. “There’s lots of filthy language, but then the writing all of a sudden moves from an f-bomb to a sentence that just lifts right off the page — it’s remarkable, the way he has with words.”

On stage, with no prepared speech written, Herring swore once during his brief acceptance speech, then barely caught himself from dropping an f-bomb of his own.

Hall saw Herring’s reaction to the win as a reflection of the kind of person the author is, and the type of book he penned in Your Breath in Charcoal.

“I described it as heart. There’s so much heart in Herring’s book — I think that came across in his acceptance speech,” says Hall.

“He’s just such a real guy, and his character is so real and struggling, but genuine, making mistakes — but also this amazing heart in the middle of that.”

ben.sigurdson@winnipegfreepress.com

Ben Sigurdson

Ben Sigurdson
Literary editor, drinks writer

Ben Sigurdson edits the Free Press books section, and also writes about wine, beer and spirits.

Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.

Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Giller winner not chosen until morning of awards

Ben Sigurdson 6 minute read Preview

Giller winner not chosen until morning of awards

Ben Sigurdson 6 minute read 2:00 AM EST

On Nov. 16, a fisherman/carpenter from Murray Harbour, P.E.I. took to a Toronto stage to accept one of Canada’s most lucrative literary prizes — 43-year-old Nicholas Herring had just been named the winner of the $100,000 Giller Prize for his sophomore novel Your Breath in Charcoal.

Chosen from over 150 works of Canadian fiction, Herring’s novel follows a couple of Maritime lads in the 1990s who venture off the island to Ontario to try and make a go of it in construction. His book was chosen as this year’s Giller winner by a nine-person jury of independent booksellers from across Canada, a first for the prize.

Among those booksellers was McNally Robinson Booksellers co-owner Chris Hall.

The typical Giller jury is made up of five people: a mix of Canadian and international authors, including a former winner of the prize. In August 2025, however, Hall received a call from Giller Prize executive director Elana Rabinovitch asking if he would be interested in being a 2026 juror on a larger jury with other booksellers.

Read
2:00 AM EST

Neutrality not the same as impartiality

John R. Wiens 5 minute read Preview

Neutrality not the same as impartiality

John R. Wiens 5 minute read 2:00 AM EST

Recently, Alberta proposed Bill 38, which would establish legislative requirements for institutional neutrality policies across the province’s post-secondary sector.

Under pressure from political leaders, universities across the globe are lining up to embrace the principle of “institutional neutrality,” enshrining commitments to refrain from adopting official positions on contested political, social, or moral questions of the day

This policy shift has been both swift and striking. Since 2023, in the United States more than 160 colleges and universities have adopted institutional neutrality policies. In the United Kingdom, a 2026 study found that 18 per cent of universities had formalized a commitment to institutional neutrality.

The reasons for and the ways in which this is unfolding are cause for real concern.

Read
2:00 AM EST

Letters, Nov. 16, 2026

7 minute read Monday, Nov. 16, 2026

Another one sides with ‘bus’

Re: Route 90 expansion mayor’s next priority (Nov. 9)

Would the two extra lanes proposed for widening Route 90 be better utilized as a (Bus Rapid Transit) BRT to possibly be upgraded in the future as Light Rail Transit (LRT) lines?

The current CN line running north and south from Taylor Avenue to north of Academy Avenue would be a good alternative for a LRT, but the feasibility study headed by Lloyd Axworthy would have to be consulted. That would involve collaborations with all three levels of government as well as the owner of the rail line.

Wilson-Raybould no-shows angered senators

Joan Bryden, The Canadian Press 5 minute read Friday, Feb. 15, 2019

OTTAWA - Former justice minister Jody Wilson-Raybould angered senators by refusing to give testimony on a change to the Criminal Code that is now at the centre of allegations that she was improperly pressured to help SNC-Lavalin avoid criminal prosecution.

The Criminal Code amendment was stuffed into an omnibus budget implementation bill last year and got little scrutiny from MPs on the House of Commons finance committee.

But when it got to the Senate, the upper chamber's legal and constitutional affairs committee was tasked with scrutinizing the provision, which allows prosecutors to negotiate remediation agreements, a kind of plea bargain, in cases of corporate corruption.

The committee held extensive hearings last May and heard from an array of expert witnesses, including Justice Department officials, who suggested that some questions were best put to the minister of justice. The committee invited Wilson-Raybould but she did not show up. In her stead, the government sent her parliamentary secretary, Liberal MP Marco Mendicino, and Public Services Minister Carla Qualtrough.

Updated take on once-obscure opera becomes a powerful testament to education, curiosity and leadership

Jen Zoratti 7 minute read Preview

Updated take on once-obscure opera becomes a powerful testament to education, curiosity and leadership

Jen Zoratti 7 minute read 2:00 AM EST

When Neema Bickersteth was invited to sing the title role in a concert version of Scott Joplin’s Treemonisha about a decade ago, she was floored by the fact she had never heard of it.

“I didn’t even know it existed. It was just like, what? This is an opera that Scott Joplin wrote, and we don’t know it?” the Alberta-born, Toronto-based soprano says.

Now, she knows it well. Bickersteth has been singing the role of Treemonisha in Scott Joplin’s Treemonisha: A Musical Reimagining since it was first developed by Toronto performance company Volcano and a creative team led by Black women artists in 2016.

But for too long, the original work, which makes its Western Canadian debut this week courtesy of Manitoba Opera at the Centennial Concert Hall, had languished in obscurity.

Read
2:00 AM EST

Meng decision may affect fate of Canadians: expert

Amy Smart, The Canadian Press 6 minute read Preview

Meng decision may affect fate of Canadians: expert

Amy Smart, The Canadian Press 6 minute read Tuesday, May. 26, 2020

VANCOUVER - A former ambassador to China says Wednesday's decision in the extradition case of Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou could also determine the fate of two Canadians detained in China.

David Mulroney, who served as Canada's ambassador to the People's Republic of China between 2009 and 2012, said if Meng is released then he expects China will eventually follow suit and release Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor.

"I think the Chinese would wait for a few months possibly, but then they would wrap up their case against the two Canadians and they would probably come home," Mulroney said in an interview on Tuesday.

The detention of Kovrig and Spavor is widely seen as arbitrary retaliation against Canada for the arrest of Meng, who is wanted on fraud charges in the United States.

Read
Tuesday, May. 26, 2020