Letters, Nov. 18
Advertisement
Read this article for free:
or
Already have an account? Log in here »
To continue reading, please subscribe:
Digital Subscription
One year of digital access for only $1.44 a week*
- Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
- Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
- Access News Break, our award-winning app
- Play interactive puzzles
*Billed as $5.77 plus GST every four weeks. After 52 weeks, price increases to the regular rate of $19.95 plus GST every four weeks. Offer available to new and qualified returning subscribers only. Cancel any time.
To continue reading, please subscribe:
Add Free Press access to your Brandon Sun subscription for only an additional
$1 for the first 4 weeks*
- Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
- Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
- Access News Break, our award-winning app
- Play interactive puzzles
*Your next Brandon Sun subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $17.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.
Read unlimited articles for free today:
or
Already have an account? Log in here »
A complex challenge
I have been more than a bit surprised at the generally negative reaction to Premier Wab Kinew’s recent comments about getting rid of the federal Indian Act.
I have no reason to believe that the premier did not contemplate the elimination of the act without first undergoing a process of consultation and accommodation of the treaty and aboriginal rights that the Constitution of Canada guarantees to the “Indian” people.
Such a transitional process is, or should be, a matter of common knowledge and understanding, particularly in Manitoba.
I served on a federal Royal Commission between 1991-96 that was set up to advise Canada on its aboriginal policy. As part of its 16-point mandate, the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP) examined the Indian Act in its historical and legal detail in 71 pages of Vol. 1 of a five-volume final report.
The commission then outlined in 218 pages of Vol. 2, Transitional measures on the Road to Self-Government as an optional path to emancipation from the federal administration of Indian affairs by the Indian Act.
The RCAP proposed the elimination of the act, but not without dealing with the status quo that the act imposed for well over 100 years.
The challenges First Nations face in getting rid of the act are evident from the eventual demise of the attempt to eliminate it in Manitoba. I refer to the “dismantling” initiative under the leadership of former national chief Phil Fontaine and minister Ron Irwin in the 1990s. That process is a lesson in the challenges of making change.
As an observer, it seems to me that Kinew’s remarks are better interpreted in the context of what I view as common knowledge today; the review and analysis of a well-publicized royal commission, as well as a recent practical attempt to eliminate the Indian Act in Manitoba.
Paul Chartrand
Winnipeg
Fix roads first
Re: Route 90 mayor’s next priority (Nov. 10)
Our mayor is determined to spend over $757 million on his next top infrastructure project. Inevitable cost overruns will drive this figure higher.
Property and hidden water taxes will pay for it. This on the heels of the closure of several public swimming pools, arenas, countless Band-Aid fixes to our crumbling streets and roadways and an escalating homelessness and poverty crisis.
This is near the top of my list for why I did not vote for Scott Gillingham as mayor.
Tuesday’s paper included a diagram of the proposed Kenaston Boulevard project showing another reason why I did not vote for him: trees, green space and houses will also be removed to build concrete bicycle paths beside Kenaston, paths that might be used by a dozen individuals a week for about five months a year. More millions.
Replacing the St. James bridge may be absolutely necessary, but hundreds of additional millions will be spent so that vehicles, most with single occupants, can travel from the North End to IKEA (and vice-versa) about three minutes faster than they do today.
Meanwhile, more potholes, closed public recreation facilities, transit issues, policing and public safety issues, etc., fester.
I hope our new councillors have the common sense and foresight to ask for, nay, demand, that the top infrastructure projects start with residential streets in older, well-established areas of the city (St. James, St. Vital, Seven Oaks, North End, etc). as well as more swimming pools, rec centres, arenas and other public venues used every day.
Removing houses, trees and green spaces for wider concrete roads should not be acceptable. Furthermore, we need to follow the example being set by other cities — no new expensive cycling routes until all existing routes are fully audited for construction and maintenance costs as well as current daily use. This audit should be exclusive of residential streets such as Wellington Crescent from Academy west to Assiniboine Park and along Wolseley Avenue, which will artificially inflate results. It must be public information, too.
Mr. Mayor and councillors, our city is in desperate need of vision and leadership. Be bold. I hope you are up to the task.
Todd Pennell
Winnipeg
Time for city to move forward
Re: Kenaston project both pricey and risky (Editorial, Nov. 16)
Winnipeg is at a crossroads, with the potential to change our trajectory to a more forward-thinking city. With a significant number of new councillors, I am hoping we will have enough that will now fight the status quo which has us lagging behind many other cities.
Widening Kenaston is one example. Study after study shows widening transportation routes leads to only short-term gains. At the same time it commits the city to maintaining more infrastructure it can ill afford. And it removes that money from other areas that so desperately need it, like downtown and its issues. Rather than supporting routes from urban sprawl, areas that suck up infrastructure costs, downtown pays a hefty amount of our municipal taxes.
And who wants to live downtown? Younger people make up a significant portion. But young people are progressive. They want to see good transit, active transportation and other environmental initiatives. They want a thriving downtown. They want to see composting, trees preserved, help for the homeless and other initiatives that come with a progressive agenda.
Take the money left over after the necessary parts like sewer separation, etc., from Kenaston, stop the Chief Peguis extension and use that money to show we are now a city moving forward, not the Neanderthal of the past.
Ingrid Ostick
Winnipeg
Where does the buck stop?
I am appalled by the laissez-faire attitude taken by the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority (WRHA) with regard to the lack of consistent care provided to Tom Landy (No improvement in home care for desperate man with degenerative disease, Nov. 12).
I have many friends who require home care and the level of consistency of care and the availability of home-care providers has been slowly eroding over the past few years. Patients are not the only people who have complaints about the WRHA. The home-care workers are also treated poorly by the supervisors who assign caseloads, and in recent months the workers have been bounced around from one part of the city to another.
The WRHA places barriers between those who need care and those who give it, whether that is in the home or in the hospitals. Is it time for an independent assessment of the WRHA and its ability to provide the best care for the people of Winnipeg?
When one thinks of all those high-priced arbiters of who gets care and who doesn’t, the mind boggles. Is the organization waiting in hope that Tom Landy will die before he can raise any more objections to the cavalier way in which he has been treated, thereby solving the problem for the WRHA?
Rene Jamieson
Winnipeg
Roads and safety
Re: Being a pedestrian in Winnipeg not for the faint of heart (Nov. 14)
I would suggest that driving in Winnipeg would not be for the faint of heart either.
According to the MPI’s Oct. 22 dashboard, year to date, there has already been over 24,000 collisions in Winnipeg alone. And that does not include any that have not been reported.
Debbie Ristimaki
Winnipeg