2022 Notebook: Charting the unexpected direction of Twitter

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 15/12/2022 (1397 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

THE BACKGROUND: Billionaire Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter in 2022 began what would turn out to be an upending of one of the world’s predominant social media platforms.

It’s an upheaval that is still continuing — fueled by Musk’s actions after he took over, his approaches to free speech and advisory oversight, how users’ feeds are changing, who can say what — and, of course, the tweets he casts into the world each day. The shift in Twitter under Musk has caused some users to abandon the platform, others to double down on it and some critics to express worry about its direction and the voices it is amplifying.

Here, Barbara Ortutay, who has been covering social media for more than a decade for The Associated Press, talks about the events of the year around Twitter and its sale, and delves into her reporting — and into why Twitter still matters to so many.

___

BARBARA ORTUTAY, AP technology writer:

It was all the way back in January that Elon Musk, one of the world’s richest men, started buying shares of Twitter, which wouldn’t be that weird on its own. But that’s when we started paying attention that something might be happening.

We’re used to covering companies buying other companies. But we’re not used to covering people buying companies so much, and certainly not the world’s richest man buying this communications ecosystem that hundreds of millions of people depend on. So it wasn’t just a business story or a mergers and acquisitions story. It symbolizes so much of what’s going on in tech, and online speech, and also in the economy and who has power in this world. I couldn’t look away. By the end of the summer, things were changing almost daily. We had to cover it as a news story, but at the same time, we were covering this thing on Twitter. Journalists have a very special relationship with Twitter, for better and for worse. We communicate on it. We see what other people are up to. We look for sources. It’s huge. So sometimes it felt like a little bit like the rug was being pulled out from under us.

There’s a lot of chaos. There’s a lot of noise. It’s very easy to fall into just covering the loudest voices or the biggest storyline. So we made a decision pretty early on to focus on the people who use Twitter. And I think that that resulted in a lot of interesting stories. For us, it was important to take a step back so that we didn’t just become his megaphone — like “Musk did this,” “Musk said that,” because also he was changing his mind so quickly. He would say one thing one day, and then turn around and say something the opposite the next day. So you have to put it in context. And we can also cover it in a way like: Who is who is affected by the rise of extremism on Twitter? What does that do to people? How does that actually silence speech?

Winnipeg Free Press | Newsletter

Paul Samyn | Editor's Note

A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom.

Sign up for Paul Samyn | Editor's Note

Sign Up

I consent to the Terms and Conditions, Cookie and Privacy Policies.

I consent to the CASL agreement.

One thing that’s important to understand is that Twitter is not just in the United States. The majority of its users are not even in the U.S. So right now, a lot of the chatter about Twitter is very much focused on U.S. politics and the U.S. differences between the left and right. And 80% of Twitter users are outside of the U.S. I’m willing to go out on a limb that they do not care about, or know about, Hunter Biden’s laptop or conservative speech suppression. So even though the loudest voices on Twitter that we can see have been focused on this story, for us it’s important to take a step back and understand that most of most of the people who use Twitter, you know, are not us. And they don’t care about the same things that we do. And yet Twitter is really important to them, probably maybe even more important than it is to us.

We’ve all spent so much time ragging on Twitter and not really liking Twitter. I remember the night that that Elon Musk laid off half of Twitter, and people started quitting or looking for other platforms to go to — places like Mastodon, which is another social media platform. I started losing followers, people who left. I didn’t realize until then how much Twitter actually mattered to me. And I think that might be true for other people on the platform, too.

It has been, it still is, a community — many communities tied together. And despite a lot of other social media sites popping up right now, there’s really nothing else quite like it. I think Elon Musk realized that when he decided to buy it. I will tell you what I think is special about it: the people on it. And a huge part of that is just the diversity of countries and people and regions. And anything that’s coming up right now to replace it is way more siloed. If this goes, I’m not sure if if anything will replace it in the same way.

___

2022 Notebooks: https://apnews.com/hub/reporters-notebook