Analysis

Opinion

Artificial intelligence requires human-led thinking

Room 309, École Laura Secord 4 minute read 2:01 AM CDT

Picture this. A teacher creates an assignment using AI. There is a provocation generated by a prompt, followed by vague parameters and a generic rubric. The AI-generated emojis are left in, and the task and success criteria are not connected to the passion, interests or soul of the child.

Subsequently, the child responds using AI. The thinking and language are clearly not their own and there has been no transformative or profound educative experience to stir cognitive dissonance. The child has not been asked, or better yet invited, to engage in sophisticated thinking and work that matters to them. That matters to community.

When the child uses AI, it’s considered “cheating.”

So here we are. An opportunity lost because we are not thinking deeply about the impact of AI on our species.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Weather

Jun. 30, 6 PM: 23°c Light rain with wind Jul. 1, 12 AM: 17°c Windy

Winnipeg MB

23°C, Windy

Full Forecast

Opinion

What is the responsibility of a national institution?

Gustavo Zentner 4 minute read Preview

What is the responsibility of a national institution?

Gustavo Zentner 4 minute read 2:01 AM CDT

As we approach Canada Day, we reflect on the values that define our country: our way of life, our commitment to fairness, our responsibility to care for those in need and our collective obligation to contribute to a society built on respect, dialogue and shared responsibility.

Yet, as we celebrate these principles, we must also recognize troubling signs that some of our national institutions are failing to uphold the very commitments that make Canada unique. When institutions allow one-sided narratives, incomplete historical context and a lack of meaningful engagement to override reason, transparency and responsibility, they create a dangerous precedent.

There is perhaps no clearer example of this challenge than what has unfolded at the Canadian Museum for Human Rights (CMHR) with the opening of the controversial “Nakba” exhibition.

A national museum dedicated to human rights carries a profound moral responsibility. It must be grounded in intellectual rigour, historical integrity, transparency and balance. It must create space for difficult conversation while ensuring complex histories are presented with the depth, nuance and fairness Canadians expect of a national institution.

Read
2:01 AM CDT

Opinion

Safe sport policies make a difference

Mac Horsburgh 4 minute read Preview

Safe sport policies make a difference

Mac Horsburgh 4 minute read 2:00 AM CDT

Times have changed for the better. It is now expected that sports organizations will incorporate impartiality and objectivity into investigations of allegations of misconduct and maltreatment of their athletes. The sine qua non of such investigations has been that an independent third party (ITP) must investigate these complaints.

The historical handling of maltreatment complaints has drawn significant scrutiny and criticism, most recently related to Hockey Canada’s handling of sexual assault allegations dating back to 2018 and 2003. As a result of these concerns, Hockey Canada went through a restructuring in 2022, adopting the ITP system and a national-level complaints system tied to the Office of the Sport Integrity Commissioner (OSIC).

Also in 2022, under Manitoba’s newly enacted Protecting Youth in Sports Act, all provincial sports organizations were mandated to adopt and implement the Sport Manitoba Safe Sport policy manual. For anyone in Manitoba who plays a provincial sport, the Safe Sport policy manual is well worth reading.

It lays out an extensive code of conduct and ethics policy as well as a discipline and complaints policy. The code of conduct references Sport Integrity Canada’s universal code of conduct and, as such, outlines what constitutes psychological and physical maltreatment, neglect, sexual maltreatment, grooming, boundary transgressions, discrimination and other forms of maltreatment.

Read
2:00 AM CDT

Opinion

After fire and flood, northern Manitoba gathers data

Emmanuel A. Badewa 4 minute read Preview

After fire and flood, northern Manitoba gathers data

Emmanuel A. Badewa 4 minute read Yesterday at 2:00 AM CDT

Floods and wildfires are not future risks for northern Manitoba. They are already part of life in the region.

The question is not whether a soil and water-monitoring network can stop them. It cannot. Wildfires will still burn. Floodwaters will still rise. Roads, culverts, shorelines, wetlands, lakes, and community infrastructure will still face pressure from extreme weather and environmental change.

The real question is whether northern Manitoba has the environmental evidence needed to understand what these events leave behind.

As an instructor who teaches natural resources and environmental monitoring in northern Manitoba, I see this need in practical terms. I see it when students measure streamflow and how moving water connects land, lakes, wetlands, and communities. I see it when we observe wildfire-affected landscapes and ask what fire may mean for soil stability, runoff, erosion, vegetation recovery, and water quality. I see it when students collect soil samples from burned sites and realize that environmental change is not just a classroom topic. It is happening on the land around them.

Read
Yesterday at 2:00 AM CDT

Opinion

Housing we need has to go somewhere

Jordan Farber 3 minute read Yesterday at 2:00 AM CDT

Winnipeg is facing a housing shortage. We see it in rising rents, increasing homelessness and the growing number of people struggling to find safe and affordable places to live.

Governments at every level have recognized the need for more housing and the City of Winnipeg has adopted policies such as OurWinnipeg 2045 and Complete Communities 2.0, specifically to encourage the type of development needed to address this challenge.

Yet when new housing is proposed, particularly in established neighbourhoods, opposition often follows.

The recent discussion surrounding the proposed development of a six-storey, 120-unit apartment building at 470 Des Meurons St. is one such example.

Opinion

Health boards cannot borrow credibility

Rafiq Andani 4 minute read Yesterday at 2:00 AM CDT

‘Credibility is a leader’s currency. With it, he or she is solvent; without it, he or she is bankrupt.’ — John C. Maxwell

In Manitoba health care, credibility manifests on the balance sheet. It shows up when a board asks executives to endure change, patients to trust a plan and the government to fund another deficit. Lose credibility and every decision eventually carries interest.

Dr. Alan H. Menkis, in the Free Press, recently asked: “For the patient, where does the buck stop?”

His concern was a health system with many layers: government, Shared Health, regional authorities, hospitals, boards, agreements, legal counsel and executives. Each layer can be lawful. The patient can still disappear between them.

Opinion

‘Chequebook federalism’ is no solution

David McLaughlin 5 minute read Preview

‘Chequebook federalism’ is no solution

David McLaughlin 5 minute read Saturday, Jun. 27, 2026

It’s pretty rich that the richest province in Canada wants out. Or is it?

In politics, like life, emotion often trumps fact. It fuels grievance. It creates myths that morph into “common knowledge.” Once embedded, it is strikingly difficult to change.

This is where we have arrived with Alberta’s separation movement and the October referendum on whether to “remain in Canada” or “commence the legal process … to hold a binding provincial referendum on whether or not Alberta should separate from Canada.”

By every financial metric, Albertans are the most well-off Canadians. So much so that for years the province marketed the “Alberta Advantage.” That is the factual argument. However, the separatist movement believes the province would have been even better off, but Canada wouldn’t let them. Alberta must therefore separate. That is the emotional argument.

Read
Saturday, Jun. 27, 2026

Opinion

Canada being side-swiped by Trump’s Cuba policy

Peter McKenna 5 minute read Preview

Canada being side-swiped by Trump’s Cuba policy

Peter McKenna 5 minute read Saturday, Jun. 27, 2026

Canada’s decades-long relationship with revolutionary Cuba has always been a three-country affair — with the United States frequently settling for the spurned third-wheel.

Since the early 1960s, successive U.S. governments have strenuously objected to Canadian trade and commercial engagement with the island. Officials in Washington have always believed that the Canadians were trying to make a “quick buck” at America’s expense, while simultaneously seeking to undermine the U.S. blockade of Cuba.

For almost 70 years now, Canada has had to negotiate the thorny issue of the U.S. trade embargo. Added to that was the anti-Cuba Cuban Democracy Act of 1992 and the still active 1996 Helms-Burton Law. Complicating matters further for Ottawa have been the various additions and subtractions to the unrelenting U.S. efforts to strangle the Cuban economy — particularly during the presidency of Barack Obama.

In January, U.S. President Donald Trump imposed a near-ironclad (some Russian oil is getting through), illegal fuel embargo against Cuba, using American naval vessels and U.S. Coast Guard ships. Additionally, he signed an executive order in early May to expand U.S. economic warfare, or what some call “secondary sanctions,” against those materially assisting the Cuban government.

Read
Saturday, Jun. 27, 2026

Opinion

What’s happening in our city?

Carina Blumgrund 5 minute read Friday, Jun. 26, 2026

IF you drive through certain parts of the city these days, you’ll see people bent over where they stand. Frozen mid-motion, the way fentanyl leaves a person, folded forward as if the world had simply paused them there. You’ll see people lying on the sidewalk who may be sleeping or may be something more urgent than sleeping. You’ll see it in broad daylight, in view of the bus stop, the convenience store, the school a block away.

Some days the impulse to look away from all the suffering is overwhelming. The mind reaches for something else to focus on, something less heavy, less difficult.

But there are people who don’t look away. Not because it’s easier for them. It isn’t. It’s harder, in fact, because they’re not just seeing it once from a distance. They’re walking into it, every shift, sometimes more than once in an hour.

I think about the outreach workers who carry naloxone the way the rest of us carry keys. Who have, more times than they could count, knelt down beside someone whose breathing had slowed to almost nothing, administered the medication and waited, in that terrible suspended moment, to see whether a life could be saved this time. Who have done this for strangers. Who have done this for people they’ve come to know by name, and have had to do it again, and sometimes again after that.

Opinion

Manitoba misses mark in creating inclusive classrooms

Sherry Gott 4 minute read Friday, Jun. 26, 2026

THE United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child recognizes that all children have the right to an education that helps them reach their full potential. It should develop their personalities, talents and mental and physical abilities. Actualizing these rights in the classroom, however, is not as easy in practice.

Every classroom includes learners with different strengths, challenges, identities and experiences. Some students are especially gifted while others have medical needs, require accommodations or manage complex issues that require additional, individualized support.

Under Manitoba’s appropriate educational programming legislation, students are entitled to educational programming that meaningfully supports both their academic and social lives. However, the number of students in Manitoba who require complex support in the classroom surpasses the number of resources teachers currently have available.

The Manitoba Teachers’ Society recently surveyed 3,400 Manitoba teachers about these gaps. Seventy-eight per cent said students are not getting needed support and 63 per cent reported fewer educational assistants. Eighty-one per cent identified class size, complexity and lack of support as top issues — citing an increase in students with complex needs within the last five years. Today, nearly half of teachers have six or more students with complex needs, a sharp rise from previous years.

Opinion

Colombia: Don’t rock the boat

Gwynne Dyer 5 minute read Preview

Colombia: Don’t rock the boat

Gwynne Dyer 5 minute read Friday, Jun. 26, 2026

“He won, BIG!” exulted Donald Trump on Truth Social, welcoming the victory of Abelardo de la Espriella, his preferred candidate for the presidency of Colombia, in last Monday’s election. In fact, de la Espriella won only very small, less than one per cent ahead of his left-wing opponent in the popular vote, but he did win. One per cent is enough.

Meanwhile, in Peru, right-wing candidate Keiko Fujimori is certain to win the vote count in Peru’s presidential election. This leaves only four left-wing democratic governments still standing in all of Latin America and two of them are very small: Uruguay and Guatemala. The ‘pink tide’ of the region’s recent political history has definitely gone out again.

Apart from the two giant hold-outs, Brazil and Mexico, Latin America is now almost wall-to-wall Trump-style populist regimes — and Brazil’s 80-year-old president, Luiz Inácio (Lula) da Silva, could easily lose the presidential election in October. The polls consistently show him tied with right-wing populist Flávio Bolsonaro, son of the imprisoned former president.

In Colombia, de la Espriella, a 47-year old former lawyer who calls himself ‘El Tigre’ (The Tiger), might as well have been designed by a hyper-conservative focus group. He vows to wipe out the country’s drug dealers and will welcome U.S. military help to do so. In fact, he is an American citizen himself and owns property in Miami.

Read
Friday, Jun. 26, 2026

Opinion

Why do we consult?

Stephen Borys 6 minute read Preview

Why do we consult?

Stephen Borys 6 minute read Thursday, Jun. 25, 2026

Over the past several months, I have found myself using two phrases with increasing frequency: community consultation and stakeholder engagement.

I have used them in meetings, proposals and discussions about the future of Holy Trinity Church in downtown Winnipeg. Some people nod in agreement. Others wonder whether these are simply consultant buzzwords.

Which raises a question: What do we actually mean when we talk about community consultation and stakeholder engagement?

The question feels especially timely because Holy Trinity Church is about to begin one of the most significant listening and engagement processes in its recent history — one that could help shape its future role in downtown Winnipeg for years to come. Over the coming months, parishioners, community organizations, downtown stakeholders, heritage advocates, businesses, governments and potential partners will be invited into that conversation.

Read
Thursday, Jun. 25, 2026

Opinion

Closing Corydon to traffic will be good for business

Kele Schreckenbach 4 minute read Preview

Closing Corydon to traffic will be good for business

Kele Schreckenbach 4 minute read Thursday, Jun. 25, 2026

Last week, the City of Winnipeg and Corydon Avenue BIZ announced that a stretch of Corydon Avenue between Daly and Lilac streets will be closed to car traffic on Sundays from July 5 through Sept. 6, the day before Labour Day.

This is a great move for the city. However, one concern brought up when people hear about such initiatives is “What about the businesses? Won’t they suffer from reduced visits and lose revenue because people are unable to reach them by car?”

The short answer to this question is “no.” Businesses not only do not go under, they usually end up doing better than before the initiative was announced. I would like to present two case studies to prove this: Copenhagen, in Denmark, and Groningen, in the Netherlands.

In 1962, Copenhagen closed the Strøget, an area of shops in the city centre, to drivers and car traffic. Business owners were very unhappy, thinking they would lose lots of customers. It got so bad that the man who proposed the project, Alfred Wassard, the lead city planner of Copenhagen at the time, got death threats and had to travel with bodyguards.

Read
Thursday, Jun. 25, 2026

Opinion

Call North End sewage project to account this fall

Hersh Seth 4 minute read Thursday, Jun. 25, 2026

Every few months, a water and sewer bill arrives in your mailbox, and every year it rises a little. Most of us pay without looking closely. It’s worth paying attention to now, because that bill has quietly become the way Winnipeg is funding the most expensive project in its history. This fall, it becomes a question on the ballot.

The project is the rebuilding of the North End sewage plant, now costing over $3 billion. The city has already raised rates — about $168 on the typical annual household bill in 2025 and roughly $44 more this year — with another increase of around $68 set for next year. Water and sewer rates have been rising for decades to pay for this plant.

Here is what should make you sit up. The city’s own staff warned that this year’s increase could have been much steeper — as high as 28.5 per cent — if the federal and provincial governments had not contributed more money. That shock was avoided only because Ottawa and Manitoba finally chipped in an additional $334 million.

Read that again: the difference between a manageable bump and a 28.5-per cent jump on your water bill was whether senior governments paid their share. Your bill is a dial, and they decide how far it turns.

Opinion

Depave paradise, tear up a parking lot

Erna Buffie 5 minute read Wednesday, Jun. 24, 2026

We use it to build everything from skyscrapers and shopping malls to plazas and highways, and currently, some 70 per cent of the world’s population lives in structures built from it. Today it ranks as no. 2 on the list of the world’s most consumed substances, second only to water.

It’s that ubiquitous “wonder” material called concrete, celebrated by architects and city planners everywhere because it’s cheap, strong and so malleable it’s capable of taking almost any shape. Better still, it’s fire resistant and incredibly easy to use.

With a couple of bags of cement, some sand, water and crushed stone, a single person can build a concrete shelter in just a matter of days.

But like all purported wonder materials — from polymers to plastics — concrete can be hugely destructive when used in vast quantities.

Opinion

U of W delivers lesson for downtown development

Jino Distasio 4 minute read Preview

U of W delivers lesson for downtown development

Jino Distasio 4 minute read Wednesday, Jun. 24, 2026

A few weeks back, I moderated a lively discussion on the future of Winnipeg’s downtown. It was a conversation that has been held many times before and certainly won’t be the last. Like most discussions, participants framed ideas around how to move downtown forward while touching on various challenges and successes. This included highlighting the growth of the downtown population and how major projects have driven billions of dollars into the entertainment, commercial and, increasingly, the medical sectors over the past two decades.

However, what received less attention was how higher education can play an even greater role in supporting downtown revitalization.

Over nearly three decades at the University of Winnipeg, I watched the campus grow substantially. Today, we have one of the largest footprints in the downtown. This growth was not accidental. It was shaped largely by Dr. Lloyd Axworthy, who became president in 2004. He advanced the idea that higher education must play a broader role in the community and reach more people. This was defined by the intentional effort to become more of a positive and visible presence in the downtown and the inner city. The thought was that education can leverage development while being a beacon for hope and change that extends well beyond the classroom and the lab.

This transformation began 22 years ago when I stood on Spence Street with then-president Axworthy. It was one of my first meetings with him, in which he shared a bold vision for the campus and the broader downtown. He said a starting point would be closing Spence Street to vehicle traffic. If I recall correctly, he referred to it as a four-lane highway in the heart of the campus. During his 10-year presidency, the university transformed into a bustling community of over 10,000 students, staff and faculty. Equally, it became a welcoming place for visitors to campus for events and supports.

Read
Wednesday, Jun. 24, 2026

LOAD MORE ANALYSIS ARTICLES